Skip to content

01_STAR/03_Criteria/tie_break_ladder — the STAR tiebreak ladder, worked

The happy-path side of STAR tie-breaking: elections that tie but never reach the lot, because the deterministic rungs (pairwise / score, then five-star) settle everything. This is the live, BV-backed home for the worked example in the tie-breaking ladder doc.

Contrast the two neighbours: - Flat_scores_ties/…05 — BV555/xmyf7k — every rung ties down to the random floor (LH-only). - tie_break_dead_rung/ — five-star is a dead rung (no 5s to weigh), so the tie drops to the lot.

Here, five-star and score do their job, so LH and BetterVoting agree deterministically.

Case Cast Method Winner Ties resolved by
Tied for the second finalist (BV2276, qhjyr2) Ana/Ben/Cora/Dev STAR Ana pairwise (scoring) — the first rung, on its own
Ice cream ladder (BV2180, fp62p2) ice cream STAR Strawberry five-star (scoring), then score (runoff) — lot never reached
No Condorcet winner — top-two tie (BV830, vb3xv2) A/B/C (abstract) STAR B score (runoff) — a head-to-head tie the Condorcet standard can't break

Read them in that order: BV2276 is the ladder at its shortest (one rung, done), BV2180 is what happens when that rung can't decide and five-star takes over, and BV830 moves the tie from the scoring round into the runoff.

Live on BetterVoting: vote · results ↗ (BV2276) · vote · results ↗ (BV2180) · vote · results ↗ (BV830).

⚠️ BV2276 doubles as a bug fixture. Its BetterVoting results page currently names Ben as the runoff opponent in the Race Details tables while the charts correctly name Coraissue #1484. The tabulation and the winner are unaffected; see the case page for the side-by-side.