{
  "Election": {
    "election_id": "484mbm",
    "title": "BV2263 — Bloc STAR — a three-way tie no rung can break (3 candidates, 2 seats)",
    "description": "Three voters, three candidates, two seats, scored 0-5. The ballots rotate: one voter scores Arden 3 / Blythe 4 / Corin 5, the next Arden 5 / Blythe 3 / Corin 4, the last Arden 4 / Blythe 5 / Corin 3. Every candidate therefore totals 12 stars, is preferred on 3 ballots across the head-to-head matchups, and holds exactly one score-5 vote — so the scoring round, the pairwise rung and the five-star rung all come back tied. Nothing in the ballots distinguishes the three, and the two seats can only be filled by whatever tie-breaking policy was published before the count. Run through Larry Hastings' starvote engine with the tiebreaker switched off, it declines to pick a winner at all. Full lesson & tabulation: https://masiarek.github.io/star-voting-library/07_Concepts/tabulation_engines/LH_starvote/starvote_file_format.html",
    "frontend_url": "",
    "start_time": null,
    "end_time": null,
    "owner_id": "ea09e7c7-b00d-427a-bef8-32ade437d49d",
    "audit_ids": null,
    "admin_ids": null,
    "credential_ids": null,
    "state": "open",
    "races": [
      {
        "title": "BV2263 — Bloc STAR — a three-way tie no rung can break (3 candidates, 2 seats)",
        "race_id": "c6128ea2-fae1-4f0c-99a9-8058a79138e7",
        "num_winners": 2,
        "voting_method": "STAR",
        "candidates": [
          {
            "candidate_id": "7b821b20-569a-415e-a239-06dfd56c1119",
            "candidate_name": "Arden"
          },
          {
            "candidate_id": "8db7cbe7-da5f-46e6-b06e-47f78d20c10b",
            "candidate_name": "Blythe"
          },
          {
            "candidate_id": "b59a3d91-f3d7-4076-9b38-bbf4f937930f",
            "candidate_name": "Corin"
          }
        ],
        "description": "",
        "enable_write_in": false
      }
    ],
    "settings": {
      "voter_access": "open",
      "voter_authentication": {
        "ip_address": false,
        "voter_id": false,
        "email": false
      },
      "ballot_updates": false,
      "public_results": true,
      "time_zone": "America/Los_Angeles",
      "random_candidate_order": false,
      "require_instruction_confirmation": true
    },
    "claim_key_hash": null,
    "is_public": null,
    "create_date": "2026-08-04T12:29:56.080Z",
    "update_date": "1785846596080",
    "head": true,
    "ballot_source": "live_election",
    "public_archive_id": null
  },
  "Ballots": [
    {
      "ballot_id": "b-b86kxfqh",
      "election_id": "484mbm",
      "precinct": null,
      "votes": [
        {
          "race_id": "c6128ea2-fae1-4f0c-99a9-8058a79138e7",
          "scores": [
            {
              "candidate_id": "7b821b20-569a-415e-a239-06dfd56c1119",
              "score": 3
            },
            {
              "candidate_id": "8db7cbe7-da5f-46e6-b06e-47f78d20c10b",
              "score": 4
            },
            {
              "candidate_id": "b59a3d91-f3d7-4076-9b38-bbf4f937930f",
              "score": 5
            }
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "ballot_id": "b-rybwgf7v",
      "election_id": "484mbm",
      "precinct": null,
      "votes": [
        {
          "race_id": "c6128ea2-fae1-4f0c-99a9-8058a79138e7",
          "scores": [
            {
              "candidate_id": "7b821b20-569a-415e-a239-06dfd56c1119",
              "score": 4
            },
            {
              "candidate_id": "8db7cbe7-da5f-46e6-b06e-47f78d20c10b",
              "score": 5
            },
            {
              "candidate_id": "b59a3d91-f3d7-4076-9b38-bbf4f937930f",
              "score": 3
            }
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "ballot_id": "b-jkqvcyxp",
      "election_id": "484mbm",
      "precinct": null,
      "votes": [
        {
          "race_id": "c6128ea2-fae1-4f0c-99a9-8058a79138e7",
          "scores": [
            {
              "candidate_id": "7b821b20-569a-415e-a239-06dfd56c1119",
              "score": 5
            },
            {
              "candidate_id": "8db7cbe7-da5f-46e6-b06e-47f78d20c10b",
              "score": 3
            },
            {
              "candidate_id": "b59a3d91-f3d7-4076-9b38-bbf4f937930f",
              "score": 4
            }
          ]
        }
      ]
    }
  ],
  "Results": [
    {
      "votingMethod": "STAR",
      "elected": [
        {
          "id": "8db7cbe7-da5f-46e6-b06e-47f78d20c10b",
          "name": "Blythe",
          "tieBreakOrder": 0,
          "votesPreferredOver": {
            "8db7cbe7-da5f-46e6-b06e-47f78d20c10b": 0,
            "7b821b20-569a-415e-a239-06dfd56c1119": 2,
            "b59a3d91-f3d7-4076-9b38-bbf4f937930f": 1
          },
          "winsAgainst": {
            "8db7cbe7-da5f-46e6-b06e-47f78d20c10b": false,
            "7b821b20-569a-415e-a239-06dfd56c1119": true,
            "b59a3d91-f3d7-4076-9b38-bbf4f937930f": false
          },
          "score": 12,
          "fiveStarCount": 1
        },
        {
          "id": "7b821b20-569a-415e-a239-06dfd56c1119",
          "name": "Arden",
          "tieBreakOrder": 1,
          "votesPreferredOver": {
            "8db7cbe7-da5f-46e6-b06e-47f78d20c10b": 1,
            "7b821b20-569a-415e-a239-06dfd56c1119": 0,
            "b59a3d91-f3d7-4076-9b38-bbf4f937930f": 2
          },
          "winsAgainst": {
            "8db7cbe7-da5f-46e6-b06e-47f78d20c10b": false,
            "7b821b20-569a-415e-a239-06dfd56c1119": false,
            "b59a3d91-f3d7-4076-9b38-bbf4f937930f": true
          },
          "score": 12,
          "fiveStarCount": 1
        }
      ],
      "tied": [],
      "other": [
        {
          "id": "b59a3d91-f3d7-4076-9b38-bbf4f937930f",
          "name": "Corin",
          "tieBreakOrder": 2,
          "votesPreferredOver": {
            "8db7cbe7-da5f-46e6-b06e-47f78d20c10b": 2,
            "7b821b20-569a-415e-a239-06dfd56c1119": 1,
            "b59a3d91-f3d7-4076-9b38-bbf4f937930f": 0
          },
          "winsAgainst": {
            "8db7cbe7-da5f-46e6-b06e-47f78d20c10b": true,
            "7b821b20-569a-415e-a239-06dfd56c1119": false,
            "b59a3d91-f3d7-4076-9b38-bbf4f937930f": false
          },
          "score": 12,
          "fiveStarCount": 1
        }
      ],
      "roundResults": [
        {
          "winners": [
            {
              "id": "8db7cbe7-da5f-46e6-b06e-47f78d20c10b",
              "name": "Blythe",
              "tieBreakOrder": 0,
              "votesPreferredOver": {
                "8db7cbe7-da5f-46e6-b06e-47f78d20c10b": 0,
                "7b821b20-569a-415e-a239-06dfd56c1119": 2,
                "b59a3d91-f3d7-4076-9b38-bbf4f937930f": 1
              },
              "winsAgainst": {
                "8db7cbe7-da5f-46e6-b06e-47f78d20c10b": false,
                "7b821b20-569a-415e-a239-06dfd56c1119": true,
                "b59a3d91-f3d7-4076-9b38-bbf4f937930f": false
              },
              "score": 12,
              "fiveStarCount": 1
            }
          ],
          "runner_up": [
            {
              "id": "7b821b20-569a-415e-a239-06dfd56c1119",
              "name": "Arden",
              "tieBreakOrder": 1,
              "votesPreferredOver": {
                "8db7cbe7-da5f-46e6-b06e-47f78d20c10b": 1,
                "7b821b20-569a-415e-a239-06dfd56c1119": 0,
                "b59a3d91-f3d7-4076-9b38-bbf4f937930f": 2
              },
              "winsAgainst": {
                "8db7cbe7-da5f-46e6-b06e-47f78d20c10b": false,
                "7b821b20-569a-415e-a239-06dfd56c1119": false,
                "b59a3d91-f3d7-4076-9b38-bbf4f937930f": true
              },
              "score": 12,
              "fiveStarCount": 1
            }
          ],
          "tied": [],
          "tieBreakType": "random",
          "logs": [
            {
              "key": "tabulation_logs.star.score_tied",
              "names": [
                "Blythe",
                "Arden",
                "Corin"
              ],
              "score": 12
            },
            {
              "key": "tabulation_logs.star.pairwise_too_many_candidates"
            },
            {
              "key": "tabulation_logs.star.five_star_tied",
              "names": [
                "Blythe",
                "Arden",
                "Corin"
              ],
              "votes": 1
            },
            {
              "key": "tabulation_logs.star.random_first",
              "name": "Blythe",
              "tiebreak_candidate_names": "Blythe, Arden, Corin"
            },
            {
              "key": "tabulation_logs.star.random_second",
              "name": "Arden",
              "tiebreak_candidate_names": "Blythe, Arden, Corin"
            },
            {
              "key": "tabulation_logs.star.advance_to_runoff_tiebreak",
              "names": [
                "Blythe",
                "Arden"
              ]
            },
            {
              "key": "tabulation_logs.star.runoff_win",
              "winner": "Blythe",
              "runner_up": "Arden",
              "winner_votes": 2,
              "runner_up_votes": 1,
              "equal_votes": 0
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "winners": [
            {
              "id": "7b821b20-569a-415e-a239-06dfd56c1119",
              "name": "Arden",
              "tieBreakOrder": 1,
              "votesPreferredOver": {
                "8db7cbe7-da5f-46e6-b06e-47f78d20c10b": 1,
                "7b821b20-569a-415e-a239-06dfd56c1119": 0,
                "b59a3d91-f3d7-4076-9b38-bbf4f937930f": 2
              },
              "winsAgainst": {
                "8db7cbe7-da5f-46e6-b06e-47f78d20c10b": false,
                "7b821b20-569a-415e-a239-06dfd56c1119": false,
                "b59a3d91-f3d7-4076-9b38-bbf4f937930f": true
              },
              "score": 12,
              "fiveStarCount": 1
            }
          ],
          "runner_up": [
            {
              "id": "b59a3d91-f3d7-4076-9b38-bbf4f937930f",
              "name": "Corin",
              "tieBreakOrder": 2,
              "votesPreferredOver": {
                "8db7cbe7-da5f-46e6-b06e-47f78d20c10b": 2,
                "7b821b20-569a-415e-a239-06dfd56c1119": 1,
                "b59a3d91-f3d7-4076-9b38-bbf4f937930f": 0
              },
              "winsAgainst": {
                "8db7cbe7-da5f-46e6-b06e-47f78d20c10b": true,
                "7b821b20-569a-415e-a239-06dfd56c1119": false,
                "b59a3d91-f3d7-4076-9b38-bbf4f937930f": false
              },
              "score": 12,
              "fiveStarCount": 1
            }
          ],
          "tied": [],
          "tieBreakType": "none",
          "logs": [
            {
              "key": "tabulation_logs.star.advance_to_runoff_same_score",
              "names": [
                "Arden",
                "Corin"
              ],
              "star": 12
            },
            {
              "key": "tabulation_logs.star.runoff_win",
              "winner": "Arden",
              "runner_up": "Corin",
              "winner_votes": 2,
              "runner_up_votes": 1,
              "equal_votes": 0
            }
          ]
        }
      ],
      "summaryData": {
        "candidates": [
          {
            "id": "8db7cbe7-da5f-46e6-b06e-47f78d20c10b",
            "name": "Blythe",
            "tieBreakOrder": 0,
            "votesPreferredOver": {
              "8db7cbe7-da5f-46e6-b06e-47f78d20c10b": 0,
              "7b821b20-569a-415e-a239-06dfd56c1119": 2,
              "b59a3d91-f3d7-4076-9b38-bbf4f937930f": 1
            },
            "winsAgainst": {
              "8db7cbe7-da5f-46e6-b06e-47f78d20c10b": false,
              "7b821b20-569a-415e-a239-06dfd56c1119": true,
              "b59a3d91-f3d7-4076-9b38-bbf4f937930f": false
            },
            "score": 12,
            "fiveStarCount": 1
          },
          {
            "id": "7b821b20-569a-415e-a239-06dfd56c1119",
            "name": "Arden",
            "tieBreakOrder": 1,
            "votesPreferredOver": {
              "8db7cbe7-da5f-46e6-b06e-47f78d20c10b": 1,
              "7b821b20-569a-415e-a239-06dfd56c1119": 0,
              "b59a3d91-f3d7-4076-9b38-bbf4f937930f": 2
            },
            "winsAgainst": {
              "8db7cbe7-da5f-46e6-b06e-47f78d20c10b": false,
              "7b821b20-569a-415e-a239-06dfd56c1119": false,
              "b59a3d91-f3d7-4076-9b38-bbf4f937930f": true
            },
            "score": 12,
            "fiveStarCount": 1
          },
          {
            "id": "b59a3d91-f3d7-4076-9b38-bbf4f937930f",
            "name": "Corin",
            "tieBreakOrder": 2,
            "votesPreferredOver": {
              "8db7cbe7-da5f-46e6-b06e-47f78d20c10b": 2,
              "7b821b20-569a-415e-a239-06dfd56c1119": 1,
              "b59a3d91-f3d7-4076-9b38-bbf4f937930f": 0
            },
            "winsAgainst": {
              "8db7cbe7-da5f-46e6-b06e-47f78d20c10b": true,
              "7b821b20-569a-415e-a239-06dfd56c1119": false,
              "b59a3d91-f3d7-4076-9b38-bbf4f937930f": false
            },
            "score": 12,
            "fiveStarCount": 1
          }
        ],
        "nOutOfBoundsVotes": 0,
        "nAbstentions": 0,
        "nTallyVotes": 3
      },
      "tieBreakType": "none",
      "perm": [
        "8db7cbe7-da5f-46e6-b06e-47f78d20c10b",
        "7b821b20-569a-415e-a239-06dfd56c1119",
        "b59a3d91-f3d7-4076-9b38-bbf4f937930f"
      ]
    }
  ]
}