====================================================================== SOURCE FILE: ex15_approval_yes_no.yaml TABULATED FILE: ex15_approval_yes_no_tabulated.txt ====================================================================== election_title: Exercise 15a — a Yes/No profile (which method is this?) scenario_description: |- Part (a) of Exercise 15 — "Read the ballot, name the method." 35 voters, three candidates, and a ballot that records only Yes or No per candidate — no ranking, no scores, and voters approve different NUMBERS of candidates. That combination identifies the method: this is APPROVAL VOTING. Blair wins with 28 approvals of 35 ballots (80%), ahead of Cosmo 22 and Ada 15. Note the shares add to well over 100% — approval percentages are shares of BALLOTS, not of a divided pie, and that is the tell most readers miss. A textbook-style prompt (a Yes/No table with weighted voter blocs), rebuilt here with named candidates so the columns line up A/B/C -> Ada/Blair/Cosmo. Companion file ex15_approval_pairwise.yaml re-reads these same ballots pairwise; part (b) is ex15_score_profile.yaml. Exercise page: ../ex15_read_the_ballot.md Live results: https://bettervoting.com/d4v2dh/results (BV2258, race 1 of 2 — BetterVoting's own Approval count agrees: Blair.) bv_test_id: BV2258 bv_election_id: d4v2dh bv_results_url: https://bettervoting.com/d4v2dh/results voting_method: Approval num_winners: 1 ballots: |- Count:Ada,Blair,Cosmo 15:0,1,1 8:1,1,0 7:1,0,1 5:0,1,0 expected_winners: - Blair # file: ex15_approval_yes_no.yaml ====================================================================== TABULATION RESULTS ====================================================================== --- Approval Voting (single winner) --- Tabulating 35 ballots (any non-zero score = approval). Ballots: columns = Ada, Blair, Cosmo (1 = approve; 0 = not approved) 15 × 0,1,1 8 × 1,1,0 7 × 1,0,1 5 × 0,1,0 Blair -- 28 (80%) -- Elected Cosmo -- 22 (63%) Ada -- 15 (43%) [Approval Distribution] (how many candidates each ballot approved) 65 approvals across 35 ballots — average 1.9 of 3 (range 1–2). approved 1: 5 ballots approved 2: 30 ballots [Co-Approval Matrix] Of the voters who approved the ROW candidate, the % who ALSO approved the COLUMN candidate. | Blair | Cosmo | Ada | ----------------------------------- Blair | -- | 54% | 29% | Cosmo | 68% | -- | 32% | Ada | 53% | 47% | -- | Winner — Approval Voting (single winner) Blair